Taste More. Feel at Home.

Authentic Mexican cuisine, hand crafted cocktails and family hospitality, served fresh in the heart of Nineveh Indiana.

⌖

☎

◷

✦

Good Food Brings Everyone Together.

At El Potro, great food is about more than what is on the plate. It is about authentic recipes, welcoming hospitality and moments shared around the table.

From sizzling favorites to refreshing cocktails, every visit is designed to feel warm relaxed and memorable.

Flavor Made With Purpose and Heart

01

Tradition

Authentic Mexican flavor prepared with care and attention.

02

Freshness

Fresh ingredients prepared daily for bold satisfying flavor.

03

Hospitality

Friendly service that makes every guest feel welcome.

04

Familia

A welcoming place made for family friends and community.

From Our Table

Explore Our Menu

More Than a Meal. A Family Tradition.

At El Potro, authentic food and warm hospitality come together to create moments worth sharing.

Every plate and every drink is prepared to make your visit relaxed flavorful and memorable.

Four El Potro favorites featuring bold food and colorful hand crafted drinks.

House Favorite

Pollo Loco

Savory chicken with colorful peppers onions shrimp and warm tortillas.

Grilled Favorite

Carne Asada

Grilled steak served with traditional sides and bold Mexican flavor.

Hand Crafted Cocktail

Blue Margarita

Bright refreshing citrus flavor served chilled and beautifully presented.

Fresh Crafted Cocktail

Blueberry Margarita

Fresh berry flavor with bright citrus and a smooth refreshing finish.

View Full Menu Call El Potro

Hand Crafted Cocktails Crafted to Raise a Glass.

From colorful margaritas to refreshing house favorites, our cocktails are made for good food and even better company.

Our Guests Say

★★★★★

Best Mexican restaurant around. Authentic food and great service every single visit.

Rhet Cole Google Review

★★★★★

Very nice ambiance and the food is excellent. Great service every time and the prices are fair too.

Karen Nolan Google Review

★★★★★

We have eaten at plenty of Mexican restaurants and this one is easily the best. Big portions and full of flavor.

Andrew Remillard Google Review